See now I never got the love for Tocantins. I just found so many of the characters just lacking. Coach was laffos, Tyson was great and Fischbach's learning curve was interesting to watch. Taj & Erinn were semi-interesting to a lesser extent, but after that no-one seemed worth following iykwim? To me JT was a worse winner than Bob.

In Nicaragua I found nearly every player was good to watch for one reason or another, from the very first boot all the way through. Even if it was out of hate or rolling my eyes at the screen, they all brought something to the table you know? The sole exception being LimpyKelly - who bored the hell out of me. Even invisiKelly was great despite little to no screentime :D

I've never thought about it hard enough to rank the Seasons, but offhand my own top five are some combination of Nicaragua, FvF, Amazon, PI and idk.. one of Vanuatu/Gabon/China/HvV? I think just looking at that, it's the character heavy seasons do it for me, rather than the strategy element. Like much as I like watching Yul dominate strategically (greatest strategist IMO), it's just a little boring. Give me Randy melting down and verbally abusing his tribe any day of the week.

I enjoyed Tocantins, I just wish Stephen had won. His social game got really bad in the last few days, though.

It was so weird watching Nicaragua for me, cause i was so used to watching my Survivor online. I actually didn't like that season too much at first, it was only after rewatching a couple of scenes and looking at some writeup's about it on Sucks that made me like it. Actually, Sucks changed my opinion about alot of stuff on Survivor like i use to think CI was like THE BEST SEASON EVER! and i was omg in love with the Aitu 4, but apparently on Sucks it's like one of the most boring and worst season ever so after a rewatch i was so wrong, i mean it's definatly not the worst season but i hated Yul/Becky i can't believe i didn't notice how freiking boring they are like omg. Tocantins was not that bad really, i Stephan and i taught the Coach/Debb/Tyson bullling Sierra thing was cruel so omg so lolz >3

I guess i can say my top favorites are China and Pearl Islands, i mean those seasons were just amazing! Then, like Amazon, Australia (first season i watched), FVV, EI (Cascaya <3) I think Guatema, Vanuatu and Fiji are the most underated, i actually don't get the "Fiji is the worst season crap" I was never reallly bored while watching it honestly.

Jeff and his painfully horrible opinions and Sucks hatred for him <3 lol i think that's why i love that website so much, i mean i barely know anybody at all that watched Survivor so when i started really gettin into it i went to this FB discussions and omg like 60 % of them were old grumpy casual fans with with no scence of humor at all, while at Sucks it's just a bunch of entertaining assholes who make Survivor fun :) I think the most painful Jeff moments is over the last few renuions, omg it's so fustrating him and his obsession with some of this players like Russel "THE MOST NOTORIEST SURVIVOR PLAYER EVER" like bitch please, stfu!

Vanuatu has some very fun characters in it. It always makes me laugh that the fat guy who couldn't get across the balance beam on the first challenge, won the season.

I enjoyed Nicaragua. I thought the tribe swap more or less screwed the older tribe and Marty in particular obv. The quitters also threw a wrench into the games dynamics. But the characters were interesting. At the time I was satisfied with Fabio winning but I think Chase played the better game of the 2. I wanted Holly to win towards the end bc I loved her growth as a player.

I think Vanuata and China are both excellent seasons, and I like HvV and FvF. I know I`ll take some flack for this but, I like Samoa. I thought it was real interesting and made fans out of a few of my friends who didn`t watch before. I hate Russell now so don`t get me wrong but, he was fun to watch on Samoa imo for a # of reasons. I never really watch the first few seasons, I`ve only watched Thailand of the pre PI seasons(never saw Amazon and missed all the inside jokes on asteria lol). I have tried to rewatch Borneo but I just get bored with it honestly. Its not the players or the game its just that Jeff sounds so god awful boring in it that it kills me. I`m like halfway through it maybe. I enjoy most all the seasons I have watched though.

I think you just gotta take sucks with a grain of salt and not take people seriously. I know I`m not serious with most of the shit I post there. Its just for lulz mostly.

Yeah how awesome was that! I also love that the old guys were smart enough to boot the younger ones off the start. Think it was Sarge who started it can`t remember. I may rewatch that season now that we`ve been talking about it because it was one of my favs.

My love for Tocantins is rooted largely with my shallow obsession with a certain Brendan Synnott <3 so yep. Overall I acknowledge that it was not an amazing season, but it was passable. It just has a special place in my heart.
I agree with the cast of Nicaragua being amazing, it is the only cast where I can actually and logically envision over half the cast returning, whether it be all stars or that rumored second chances (please happen..PLEASE)

alol Brenda "LimpyKelly"
@Ryan. I didn't think Samoa was horrible. And you have to admit that Russell made the game way more interesting than it would have been without him and his suspicious surplus of idols (that did save his tribe).
It was amazing watching Galu self destruct (like timbira did) and the foa foas make it to the end.
Yeah Chris's journey was fun to watch too!

Borneo was my first season which is why it also has a special place in my heart, and because it was my first, I never found it boring.

Sucks helped me out with a lot of opinions too! <3 Sucks

I'v tried to watch Borneo many times but i never keep track of it so much, i think i left of it in like episode 4. I'm definatly not gonna abandon it and when i have time and partience i'm gonna try to watch it. I actually spoiled alot of seasons before i watched some of the seasons, it ruined it a bit for me but i still was on the edge of my seat a couple of times. I only saw like half of Palau (up to where Steph left), Samoa (i lost track, i didn't like Russel so much, there was such a great cast and he took 90% of the screentime), Marquesas and Thailand. The rest i watched from beginning to finish, i didn't like Thailand so much and i was barely paing any attention. RI and SP are definatly one of the worst seasons, the only people i like in RI was Steve <3333 Franquesca and i kinda liked Steph, actually lol. I loved Edna in South Pacific, and pretty much anyone pre-merge, Cristine and Stacy a.k.a Salt and Pepper <3 and Slutney (well mostly Twitney <3)

and yeah Chris is so underated, like i don't understand how people can say he disn't deserve it. He was suppose to be first voted out and managed to convice some of his tribemates to vote out the younget fit guys and then was in the Final 7 with six girls and managed to make them turn on eachother and then win the game. Like that's a good winner.