Stranded in Greece • View topic - Day 07

Jake · **Joined:** Sun Jan 01, 2012 11:07:39 pm **Posts:** 262

I don't want to agree to a double boot, but I still don't see a reason we should be punished.
Had we stopped and said someone from your tribe posted the wrong coordinates right after they were posted, we would have won the first challenge. Since you got a freebie with cebren, we got one with pan. It may be easier to say because we won immunity, but I think us keeping immunity is fair.

Shawna · **Joined:** Sun Jan 01, 2012 11:05:44 pm **Posts:** 381

If Pan wasn't in the puzzle then it should not count, if we go get a greek dictionary in sure we will find many greek words in there, but as long as they are not in the puzzle they should not count.

Jeanne · **Joined:** Sun Jan 01, 2012 11:03:38 pm **Posts:** 243

Do you have any crosswords?

Jeff Probst · **Joined:** Thu Dec 08, 2011 2:41:11 am **Posts:** 795

IS everyone okay with doing another immunity challenge?

Penny · **Joined:** Sun Jan 01, 2012 11:08:56 pm **Posts:** 1262

We can put the tribe v tribe stuff on hold and argue this efficiently, I agree.

Firstly, last week Helios appealed against the ruling of the challenge because Asteria posted a word incorrectly (with the coordinates and stuff) now you guys had gotten away with it but we had been picked up on it. Surely thats reason enough to appeal?

Secondly, tonight's challenge we appealed against us not being allowed to use a word. Now without a list given prior, surely we are entitled to use a word that is GREEK in a word find where the rules have been stipulated that you have to find GREEK words. We also werent told about a letter limit on words either.

I think both our appeals, while Asteria are justifiably frustrated by the rulings, were justified, and I dont think you guys can argue against that.

Joanna · **Joined:** Sun Jan 01, 2012 11:04:09 pm **Posts:** 1056

as long as no one from our tribe has left like last time then yes

Jeff Probst · **Joined:** Thu Dec 08, 2011 2:41:11 am **Posts:** 795

It looks like 7 people from ASteria are here, that's plenty.

Rob · **Joined:** Sun Jan 01, 2012 11:04:37 pm **Posts:** 373

Jeff Probst wrote:

Rob wrote:

Jeff Probst wrote:

Thank you, Penny.

Enough of this Rob vs. Penny forced bs. We need to discuss this like adults.

I am willing to take action if there is reason to.

When we lost the first challenge you said it was because "it wasn't posted in the rules" so there was nothing that could be done about it.

This time, it was specifically posted in the rules, and yet you still overruled the outcome.

What specifically was posted in the rules?

About your word list or whatever. It doesn't matter that the word they found is technically a Greek word, it wasn't on your list, so it wasn't your intention of hiding it or having them find it so they shouldn't get points for it.

Imagine if we were playing a different game, like checkers. We're given a set number of things to work with. If someone happens to find another checker lying around somewhere, do they get to use it in the game for their own advantage? No.

Christy · **Joined:** Sun Jan 01, 2012 11:02:09 pm **Posts:** 455

On the real show was there any situation when Jeff revoked immunity after declaring a winner?

Jeanne · **Joined:** Sun Jan 01, 2012 11:03:38 pm **Posts:** 243

I am ok with doing another, also if we have our members present